After years of uncertainty, the New York Cosmos — one of the most iconic brands in American soccer history — are officially making their return. Slated to join USL League One in 2025, the Cosmos’ reentry marks a significant moment for fans who’ve long hoped for a revival of one of the sport’s most legendary names.
For many, this isn’t just a club. It’s a symbol.
A Club Built on Legends
Founded back in 1970, the Cosmos became a household name in the 1970s and ‘80s during the North American Soccer League (NASL) era. With global icons like Pelé, Franz Beckenbauer, Giorgio Chinaglia, and Carlos Alberto wearing the badge, the Cosmos weren’t just good — they were glamorous.
They played in front of 70,000+ fans at Giants Stadium, helped put U.S. soccer on the map, and brought international attention to a league still in its infancy. Pelé’s 1975 arrival wasn’t just a game-changer for the Cosmos — it was a watershed moment for American sports as a whole. I remember this myself growing up in Jersey, this was the era where all the higher level sports teams like the Yankees, Mets, Giants and so on were all in the midst of massive struggles, and the area took to the Cosmos as a chance to see a team to get excited for.
After NASL folded in the mid-1980s (something that crushed me 9 something year old self back in the day) the Cosmos disappeared for decades, lingering only in memory and myth. But in 2013, they returned in a reformed NASL, capturing new fans while honoring the club’s heritage. They lifted multiple titles during that modern era, showing they were more than just a nostalgia act.
The Cosmos and the U.S. Open Cup: A Proper Fit
Part of the excitement around the Cosmos’ USL return is the club’s eligibility for the Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup — America’s oldest and most democratic soccer competition.
The Cosmos made waves in the Open Cup during their 2010s rebirth, famously knocking out MLS sides like the New York Red Bulls and NYCFC in gritty, high-energy cup ties. Their presence in the tournament always added an extra layer of intrigue — a classic David vs. Goliath vibe, with the Cosmos often playing the wildcard.
With their return in 2025, fans can once again look forward to the kind of underdog storylines and regional rivalries that make the Open Cup one of the most uniquely American soccer events.
Why USL League One Makes Sense For a Round 3
Joining USL League One is a smart and strategic move and a smart move playing in Paterson NJ to build the new resume.
While fans might dream of an immediate jump to USL Championship or even Major League Soccer, League One offers a more sustainable runway. The Cosmos can rebuild on solid footing, establish local rivalries, and connect with a new generation of fans — all without the overwhelming financial pressure that higher tiers might bring.
Plus, the USL ecosystem is growing rapidly, with more media visibility, club investment, and fan engagement than ever before. A club with the Cosmos’ history entering that mix is a win for both parties..
Why This Matters
The Cosmos returning isn’t just about one team. It’s about restoring legacy, bridging generations, and proving that American soccer doesn’t have to forget its past to chase the future.
There’s something special about seeing “New York Cosmos” on a schedule again. It stirs memories, expectations, and maybe even a little magic.
And if you’re a fan of the sport — whether you remember Pelé’s run or you’re just tuning in now — that should get you excited.
- Hill Ties Record As Halifax Makes Thunderous Opening Statement
- All Lacrosse All The Time’s Weekly NLL Pick ‘Ems – Week 2
- Seals Outlast Black Bears 16–13 in Season Opener at Ottawa
- Inter Miami Ends NYCFC’s Playoff Run With 5–1 Win in Eastern Conference Final
- Mammoth Win Opener As Malcom Nets Sock Trick
