New York City FC’s postseason journey came to an abrupt end Saturday night in Fort Lauderdale, falling 5–1 to Inter Miami CF in the Audi 2025 MLS Cup Playoffs Eastern Conference Final. In front of 19,136 at Chase Stadium, Miami’s clinical finishing and second-half surge proved too much for a resilient but ultimately overmatched NYCFC side.
Miami struck twice in the opening 23 minutes, both goals coming from Tadeo Allende — the first a composed right-footed finish after a chipped ball in behind, the second a powerful header assisted by Jordi Alba and Sergio Busquets. New York City struggled to find rhythm early in a choppy, whistle-filled first half, but clawed their way back into the contest in the 37th minute.
Maxi Moralez, adding to his already-historic postseason résumé, whipped in a trademark set-piece delivery that homegrown midfielder Justin Haak attacked emphatically. His headed finish — the 20-year-old’s first career MLS Cup Playoffs goal — snapped Miami’s 262-minute postseason shutout streak and briefly injected belief into Pascal Jansen’s squad. It also made Haak the only Homegrown player in club history to score in the MLS Cup Playoffs.
New York City entered halftime down 2–1 and still very much alive. Jansen introduced Hannes Wolf after the interval, and NYCFC began the second half with renewed energy. A high turnover produced a half-chance for Moralez, and minutes later Julián Fernández nearly equalized with a first-time strike that forced an exceptional fingertip save from Rocco Ríos Novo.
But as has often been the case in Miami’s postseason run, Lionel Messi shifted momentum with one moment of brilliance. In the 67th minute, Messi combined with Mateo Silvetti, who slotted home Miami’s third to restore a two-goal cushion. From there, Miami seized full control. Substitute Telasco Segovia finished a devastating counterattack in the 83rd minute, and Allende completed his hat trick in the 89th, cementing a dominant performance from the hosts.
**“Shop NYCFC merch here 👇
Despite the lopsided final score, NYCFC’s season featured achievements worth noting. Entering the postseason as the fifth seed, the Club advanced to its third Eastern Conference Final in the last five years — the only MLS team to do so in that span. Across the past decade, just four clubs have reached three or more Conference Finals within a five-year window: NYCFC (2021, 2022, 2025), LAFC, Seattle Sounders, and Toronto FC.
NYCFC’s postseason consistency has become one of the defining traits of the franchise. The 2021 MLS Cup champions have now reached the Conference Finals or beyond in three of their nine playoff appearances. And even in defeat, several players added milestones to club history on Saturday.
Foremost among them was Maxi Moralez. At 38 years and 275 days old, the midfielder broke his own record as the oldest NYCFC player to record an assist in the MLS Cup Playoffs. The assist on Haak’s header gave Moralez his eighth career playoff helper — extending his club record — and continued a remarkable postseason run in which he registered a goal contribution in three straight matches.
Moralez remains NYCFC’s all-time leader in both playoff goals (6) and assists (8), and Saturday marked his 23rd postseason appearance for the Blues — another club record. His durability also made league history this season, as he became the oldest field player ever to start all 34 regular-season matches since MLS moved to a 34-game format in 2011.
Haak, meanwhile, continues to emerge as one of NYCFC’s most important young contributors. Saturday’s goal was his third for the Club across all competitions and made him only the second Homegrown player ever with a playoff goal contribution, joining Tayvon Gray (one assist in 2021).
Forward Agustín Ojeda also completed a notable milestone, appearing in all 39 matches this season (34 regular season, five playoff) — a testament to the 19-year-old’s durability and importance in Jansen’s first campaign.
Though the match ended painfully, both Jansen and captain Thiago Martins emphasized growth and accountability in their postgame remarks.
“When I walked in back in January to start this project, one of the things we mentioned was that we had to do better than the previous season,” Jansen said. “From an objective standpoint, that’s what we did. But to finish the season like this tells us we have a few more lessons to learn… our full focus is on next season because we have to do better again.”
Martins echoed the sentiment. “We have a young team,” he said. “Nobody expected us to be in the Conference Final, but we were here. We lost, but as a team we need to learn from this and be better for next year.”
Saturday’s final statistics reflected Miami’s sharper edge in key moments: 11 shots to NYCFC’s six, six shots on target to three, and five goals from an xG profile that highlighted their ruthless efficiency inside the box. New York City, to their credit, held nearly even possession (48.8%) and posted a higher pass accuracy (89%) but could not slow Miami’s transitions or prevent Allende from delivering a career-defining performance.
New York City’s 2025 campaign now closes with a 3-1-1 postseason record and a broader upward trajectory under Jansen. With a strong returning core, continued development from rising talents, and proven leadership from veterans like Moralez, the Club once again enters the offseason positioned among the East’s elite.
The result stings — but the foundation remains strong. And as history has shown, NYCFC rarely stays down for long.
